After she saw Jason waiting for her at the altar, Kylie tells PEOPLE, “I really remember that overall feeling of ease and bliss”

When it comes to her favorite wedding memory, Kylie Kelce can’t choose just one!

When asked about her nuptials to husband Jason Kelce, the mom of three, 31, revealed she has a few favorite moments from their special day.

The first being when she felt “terrified” before stepping out in front of everyone at the ceremony. But upon seeing her NFL star husband, 36, Kylie says her fear melted away.

“I know personally my favorite wedding memory is when I was getting ready to walk down the aisle,” she recalls to PEOPLE about their 2018 nuptials. “I was terrified not because I was about to get married but because everyone was going to be staring at me.”

Kylie says she “had worked up this sort of anticipation,” but seeing the football player waiting for her at the altar changed everything.

“As soon as our wedding planner opened the door and I could see Jason, it was as if all of the worries melted away,” she says. “So I was like, ‘Oh I just have to get to him. I can do that.’ “

“So that was like a memory where I really remember that overall feeling of ease and bliss,” she adds.

Kylie’s second favorite memory? Sitting at their sweetheart table — a small table designated exclusively for the newlyweds — at the reception.

She tells PEOPLE sitting at the table with Jason was a “really special time.”

Jason and Kylie Kelce with their three daughters.

KYLIE KELCE/INSTAGRAM

“It’s really the only time where you get to sit down and sort of catch up with each other because you’re running in opposite directions most of the day,” she explains. “Which seems counterintuitive on your wedding day, but you do get sort of split up.”

“So we loved sitting down and having dinner just the two of us,” she adds.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Kylie and Jason tied the knot on April 14, 2018 at the Logan Hotel in Philadelphia — just two months after Jason and the Philadelphia Eagles won Super Bowl LII.

The couple — who now shares three daughters, Bennett, 11 months, Elliotte, 2½, and Wyatt, 4 — met on Tinder over two years earlier.

They went Instagram-official with their relationship in November 2015, with Kylie joking, “Thank goodness you swiped right too.”